Creative composition of products with green elements

Pinterest Ads: how to take advantage of the new Campaign Optimization Score

The optimization of campaigns in Pinterest Ads It features a new reference to detect what should be reviewed before increasing investment. Pinterest introduced the Campaign Optimization Score in September 2026, a score that correlates campaign settings, creative variety, and the quality of data signals with improvement recommendations within Ads Manager.

According to the Official Pinterest guide for seasonal campaigns, This score can be consulted when creating, editing or duplicating campaigns. At Karmina we propose using it as a support for diagnosis, comparing its suggestions with the commercial objective, the available resources and the real experience of the people who visit the website.

Understanding what problem the score indicates

A recommendation is useful when it helps formulate a specific question: whether creative variants are missing, whether the campaign receives sufficient information, or whether the catalog correctly reflects the offer. Improving a score does not automatically equate to improving profitability, Therefore, each change should be based on a hypothesis that can be verified through business results.

For a decoration brand, for example, a campaign could appeal to people planning a renovation, while another would focus on a product available for immediate purchase. Although both share visual resources, their results should be interpreted considering these distinct decision moments and the time that may elapse before purchase.

Producing variety with a strategic intent

An ad library gains value when it allows exploring different approaches to a single proposal. Displaying a product in context, explaining its measurements, and showing a combination of uses meets different needs, while changing only the background color provides more limited learning. We propose organizing production based on these questions and maintaining a consistent visual identity.

This planning connects the Branding and design work with the Social ads campaigns. The agency can help turn product knowledge into pieces that are understandable, attractive, and appropriate for each context of discovery, while avoiding the pressure to generate versions that dilute the brand message.

Review the catalog and the measurement before scaling

Creative quality needs a consistent operational foundation. If an image sparks interest in a sold-out product or leads to a page with contradictory information, the journey loses effectiveness. That’s why we recommend reviewing prices, availability, links, and conversion actions alongside the campaign, coordinating the teams that maintain the store and the media.

The decision to increase the budget must be based on proven results, As confirmed sales, acquisition costs, or useful insights based on the business. A periodic review can capture the applied change, its rationale, and the observed outcome, so that the team accumulates learning rather than following isolated recommendations.

At Karmina, we understand Pinterest as an option that should fit into the brand strategy and into the habits of its audience. If your company already works with the channel or wants to evaluate its potential, we can review together creativity, catalog and measurement to define a test with clear priorities and an investment aligned with the objective.

AUTHOR
Karmina Team
We are a group of experts committed to helping brands grow through effective digital strategies. With a clear vision and a collaborative approach we offer customised solutions that respond to the specific needs of each client.
If you liked this content, share it!
DISCOVER

our blog

Enviar CV Enviar brief Talk to Karmina